Working In and Out of the Archive

With Reena Katz Jesal Kapadia and Brian McCarthy, and Naeem Mohaiemen
in collaboration with

At TPW Gallery R&D, Toronto
Images Festival
10-26 April, 2014

<style type="text/css">A:link {  }</style>

Working In and Out of the Archive is a web-based video platform that offers a practical technical and legal framework through which video footage can be shared, cited and reused. proposes that film and video "production" can be thought of in an expanded way. For example, by a filmmaker publishing video that is not a film, a researcher probing documentary images, a film editor organizing footage using the archive, a writer commenting on one or many video pieces, an artist working online, or an institution offering archives for public use. was launched publicly in 2008, and is a collaboration between CAMP, Alternative Law Forum and In 2013 this group also launched, which aims to act as an online encyclopedia for Indian cinema.

As a means of exploration – looking at its contents, structures, and possibilities – Gallery TPW and Images Festival invited a group of artists to respond to Working In and Out of the Archive presents the results of these commissioned explorations, with contributions by Jesal Kapadia & Brian McCarthy, Reena Katz, and Naeem Mohaiemen, along with Shaina Anand, Ashok Sukumaran, Zinnia Ambapardiwala and Jan Gerber of


Notes for a Non-Capitalist Cinema
Jesal Kapadia and Brian McCarthy

In the face of capitalist responses to environmental and economic crisis, in which the notion of “property” is often expanded or intensified – whether as territorial enclosure, forced extraction and privatization of natural resources, or the privatization of collective knowledge production in the university – notions of withdrawal and autonomous escape from the destructive machine of capitalism take on a variety of forms.

Kapadia and McCarthy's participation in this project is designed to visualize the ways in which spontaneous collective actions and reconfigured notions of “property” can take root in a notion of life itself. A new addition to the archive, their work contributes and annotates footage shot by Kapadia in the northeast Indian region of Sikkim. It focuses on activists from ACT (Affected Citizens of Teesta river) and members of the Lepcha tribe, then linking this footage with other material in by various filmmakers, researchers and artists. The project considers a range of non-capitalist implications and manifestations of the footage and documented actions: the potentiality of land without the spectre of monetization; free knowledge production or Lok Vidya (people’s knowledge) that exceeds the territorial enclosure of the private university; and reclamation of the right to be. The possibilities of poetically interrupting the archive and creating new forms of visualizations are endless, yet what remains to be seen is if desires are rearranged and new subjectivities with a will to social justice are born.
Keywords: Hunger Strike, Property, Territory, Duration, Non-Capitalist Life, Lok Vidya, Collective Pedagogy, Ordinary Life.

The Shobak Tapes (1993-1994)
Naeem Mohaiemen

Twenty years ago, Mohaiemen started work on an oral history of the 1971 war that split Pakistan and created Bangladesh. At that time, the local context of memorializing was deeply polarized, perhaps only superseded 20 years later by the "Shahbag movement" of 2013. Back then in 1993, symbolic trials at Ramna Park in Dhaka saw a crowd of thousands assemble, chanting the demand about the accused 1971 war criminals: "hang them." However, the next year, the most symbolic of the alleged war criminals had obtained Bangladeshi citizenship in a Supreme Court case (Bangladesh Vs. Professor Golam Azam and others, 1994, 23 CLC (AD). In the backdrop of this heated environment, Mohaiemen began his project to document stories of 1971 as "evidence" for a reckoning. The people he was interviewing exhibited a surprising ennui and cynicism– both about the contested record of 1971, and the schizophrenic post-independence present. Unable to resolve these contradictions, and continually hamstrung by his own binary ideas about the “good war,” Mohaiemen eventually abandoned the entire project, experiencing over the next few years a gradual alienation from the field of historiography in Bangladesh. He began moving to the visual arts as a space that allowed him more incomplete, speculative, and "grey zone" conversations about the 1971 war. After a gap of twenty years, he is uploading the 80 hours of interviews, recorded on hi-8, to, thus beginning a process of making sense of this failed project– especially the shifts in his own subject position.

Keywords: Bangladesh, Pakistan, India, 1947, 1952, 1971, Partition, Independence, Memory, War Crimes, Reconciliation

People Act Dance, Make and Annotate

Crossing the Everyday Life of Video

There is everyday life. And there is the everyday life of video. A peculiar cousin of the ordinary in general, is the video ordinary: made up of non-square pixels, proliferating handheld cameras, CCTV, citizen journalists, exacting filmmakers, pervasive television, and all the things that are at stake with and through these things.

All gestures in video should be measured, or rubbed up against, its own ordinary. is an archive primarily of footage and not films. It tries to catch this ordinary, and some of its qualities and evolution, in the Indian context in particular. It collects materials and works intensively through them to try and make sense of intentions, technologies, accidents and effects. It asks whether a film can be beautiful from the inside as well as the outside. It thus enquires about not only in what is visible, but also about the backend in which machines or souls that propel or cast images and sounds in a particular way. Even though the video ordinary is constantly overflowing and receding from our attention, tries to parse some of it, for threads that may lead us to new paths.

This hour-long assembly from, made and presented using the website, tells a story of the evolution of the video everyday; its practices, effects, appearances and affirmations in relation to an everyday life that itself is changing.

The Razia Sessions
Reena Katz aka Radiodress with: Maricruz Alarcón, Sharlene Bamboat, Andréa de Keijzer, Nasrin Himada, Laura Taler, Diana Younes and Alize Zorlutuna

In the Queering Bollywood section of the archive, there is a short clip from Razia Sultan (1983, dir. Kamal Amrohi, Urdu).  The film is based on the life of Razia Sultan (1205–1240), the only female Sultan of Delhi (1236–1240). The clip depicts a monologue by one of Razia’s many suitors.  His plea details a long list of sacrifices for the people and the land.  It ends with a petition for Razia to recognize his body, one on which “…many wounds of sacrifice can be reckoned.”

Without responding to the suitor Razia beckons her companion to stand.  They kiss, and walk away together, holding hands.
For The Razia Sessions, Radiodress asked seven of her bi- and poly-linguist comrades, lovers, friends and kin to teach her the thwarted lovers’ phrase in a language other than English over the internet.  Radiodress will do her best to learn the phrase well in the short time they have together.  Sometimes, the phrase is untranslatable, other times it is hybridized with English.  Often the teachers had to ask their own comrades, lovers, friends and kin to help them with translation.  The duets traverse the mistakes together - stumbling, laughing and sharing the gaps each lingual fumble evokes.

The Razia Sessions will be recorded live during the Images Festival at TPW’s R&D space, and uploaded to the site along with their transcriptions.

Thursday-Saturday, April 10-12: 4pm
Tuesday-Thursday, April 15-17: 4pm
Saturday, April 19: 1:30pm

The video art programme of the 2021 Asian Art Biennial

Presented by

is an ongoing public-access media archival project, centered around video as a medium of documentation, collection, argumentation and exchange. Its objective is to consolidate, densely annotate, and make available online several scattered collections of video material, to begin with in Mumbai and Bangalore. is a collaboration between, CAMP, Majlis, Point of View, the Alternative Law Forum, and other future contributors.

Fwd: Re: Archive

The central event of a month-long gathering organised around the 10th anniversary of the footage archive, and the 5th anniversary of

Into the Midst Workshop

Months long workshop initiated by a group of artists in and around Delhi. To analyse contemporary mediation and media theory as a general phenomenon, to discuss emerging practice and theory, and to produce new work.
Part 1 @Sarai, April 20-22, 2024

Broken Cameras

The Neighbour Before the House
Al Jaar Qabla Al Daar
الجار قبل الدار

What the Cameras Saw and Remembered

Two films by CAMP
Al Jaar Qabla Al Daar (The Neighbour before the House)
From Gulf to Gulf to Gulf

Captial Circus (2009)

The Unfaithful Octopus
MAIIAM Contemporary

To See is To Change

with Bombay Tilts Down (2022) and A Photogenic Line, (2019) as part of Photo 24, Melbourne.
In this pair of large-scale works, CAMP explore two sides of their practice; one that produces experimental film and video, often with unusual equipment and angles of participation, and another that creates and animates archives of moving images, documents and photography.


Low-End Therapy
By Swadesi crew Kaali Duniya (Bamboy/Tushar Adhav) with guest MC's Kranti Naari, Pratika, MC Mawali, Khabardar Revolt.
BassBrahma and RaakShas Sound
Equality on the dance floor.


A tour of the work with CAMP in three acts.
12 January 7 pm, ft. Bamboy
13 January 6 pm
14 January 7:30 pm
20 January 7 pm

Bombay Tilts Down in Mumbai!

7-channel environment. 13 mins, on loop with two alternating soundtracks

A vertical landscape movie in facets. Filmed remotely by one CCTV camera from a single-point location atop a 35-floor building on E. Moses Road during the pandemic.

All Events