In Cameras Res, 2019

De Appel, Amsterdam

On three screens, a city-symphony filmed by automated CCTV cameras in Amsterdam. The optical and motor capacities of these cameras are pushed to an extreme. Certain human subjects reappear near or far in the images, suggesting a form of reciprocal knowledge or intent, a secret pact between cameras and people.

In Cameras Res is an exhibition in which CAMP suggests the optical equivalent of the literary concept (in Latin) In Medias Res, in which the narrative begins in the middle of a plot, or evolutionary sequence. 
The point at which it enters is the camera itself.

An In-Camera edit is one done without a separate editing process, such as by a person using a film camera.
An In-Camera proceeding in the legal sense, is one from which spectators and jurors are excluded, thus the opposite of a public trial.

For this three-channel moving image installation, the resulting project of a De Appel
 commission from CAMP, CCTV cameras were programmed to film landscape sequences in Amsterdam. In Cameras Res (2019) engages contemporary image-making from “inside the box”, re-working the “patrol” function of the camera, pushing its optical and motor capabilities to the edge.
This continues CAMP’s long-time critical engagement with the simultaneous advances in visual surveillance technology and cinema.

In Cameras Res takes its points-of-view from Amsterdam’s historical buildings, the former Royal Dutch Shell Headquarters (now A’DAM Tower), the former NHM building (Netherlands Trading Society, now Stadsarchief Amsterdam) and the former Tetterode printing foundry (now artist ateliers), connecting them to the surrounding landscape via camera-controlled shots.

Each film in the exhibition was captured from a single camera position, and each uses a distinct editing technique. We see several micro and macro versions of the city, in different weather and light conditions. The recurrence of certain human subjects in the frame, near or far, suggests a form of reciprocal knowledge or intent, a choreography or interplay of patterns. Here, CAMP speculates about future images and future awareness, via the question: What can cinema be in this time where there are more cameras than people?

In Cameras Res
3-channel HD CCTV video
Camera Software: Jan Gerber
De Appel production team: Lucie von Eugen, Charlie Rosa Jansen, Liza Nijhuis 
Actors: Sjoerd Bartlema, Lu Klassen
Thanks to Rachael Rakes, Niels Van Tomme, Maaike Lauwaert, Tom Makkes, Abhishek Pradhan, Finbar van Wijk & Sjoerd Tim (Sjaft), Yashaswini Raghunandan.

Phone video from the opening at De Appel.

Interview with CAMP - Rachael Rakes

This project is the most recent piece in your long-sustained engagement with the mechanics of capture. Can you discuss some of the origins of this line of work?

CAMP: At first, it comes from a deep criticism and review of the documentary relation between ethnography and cinema. CAMP’s practice posits this as a set of triangular relationships between subjects, authors and technologies. Their dynamics create different regimes of images, sometimes in very subtle ways. The camera and compositing technologies are an important but less-observed factor. For example the first cameras we bought more than a decade ago were static CCTV cameras at €10 a piece, that along with a video multiplexer and hundreds of meters of coax and XLR cables, cost less than a small mini-dv camera. These CCTV systems were then coupled with household TV screens and microphones to create day-long neighbourhood conversation zones across an urban village in New Delhi, in a project called Khirkeeyaan. The gaze of lens-based authorial filmmaking was fractured here, along the cross-hair grid of a CCTV multiplexer. Subjects looked out at us and at each other, and could enter and leave.
In an even earlier work by Ashok (Windscreen), the mechanics of video capture was clear in a sculpture made from paper pixels held up by wind, interrupted in jagged pixelated forms by the subjects body. The triangular ecosystem of image and narrative generation extends into systems of storage and distribution. In the early years we worked with FM, parasite cable and TV infrastructures, local broadcasting and narrow casting as well as the early internet. There was a desire to be intimate with large ecologies of communication and capture, but also to make our own, with our own set of rules. For us, that’s what new cinema is about: the navigation of these landscapes and new forms of address it produces.

Perhaps we could also talk about how these mechanics have changed over time, along with changes in technology and cinematic aesthetics?

CAMP: We can move from the CCTV/cable TV mash-up described above, which is really about an alternative imagery for television, to what happens with other visual institutions and practices. We are not fans of “poor image” theories because images have travelled in many directions not defined by resolution or originality. In our film From Gulf to Gulf to Gulf there is a sort of equivalence between low and hi-res images, and there are over 25 camera people in the credits. So the typical ethnographic subject has moved location and is now pointing cameras at the world, replete with music from their onboard playlists.

We did projects by attaching cheap point-and-shoot still/video cameras to telescopes, by entering CCTV control rooms, or with leaked security footage. There is an interest in how these technologies and the people working with them can be encouraged to hybridise and think about images in ways not “captured” by their current deployment. After all, the whole of CCTV is a kind of monumental ecosystem of image waste, waiting for an event. We are interested in where in the network we can add a machine, a person, an idea, a new practice to trouble this settled function of images. We also run an online footage archive,, which is about paying a lot of attention to that waste, to what gets cut out at a particular time and place. Several of our recent projects use a single PTZ camera, a bit like in the Camera Obscura tradition, to disturb its workings from the very basic premises.

You have made projects using CCTV or surveillance tech in several cities—where some elements of the cityscape are necessary instigators in the works—I’m curious how this has informed your sense of these places?

CAMP: Yes, this is very interesting and specific. For example, in 2008 we made a
 film using the 206 cameras inside the then-largest mall in Europe (CCTV Social:
Capital Circus) , which was rebuilt to cover the historic city-centre after the old mall in Manchester was bombed by IRA. “Saved by the bomb”, said the tabloids as city planners spruced up so-called “Gunchester” by kickstarting a regeneration campaign with massive CCTV infrastructure. The match-cut continuity of this lm was inspired from another project where we, and subsequently members of the public, had entered CCTV control rooms in Manchester (CCTV Social: Coldclinic) and seen camera operators in action. In both these cases, hundred-plus participants in front of the cameras signed special image release forms (so that we could access the footage under provisions of the UK data protection act) that were about a claim to their own appearance as CCTV subjects, as much as a classic image release.

In Palestine, in and around East Jerusalem, 8 families filmed from the privacy of their homes, watching the feed from rooftop Pan-Tilt-Zoom cameras, on their TV sets (The Neighbour before the House). A film production made possible without acknowledging 
or seeking permission from the Israeli state, and re-orienting the subject position of an eternally interned citizen. Instead of bearing witness in the usual way, these families controlled cameras which were set at a vantage point on their own homes, and narrated stories of their life and the landscape of their city. The result is very close to what Masao Adachi and his comrades referred to as ‘landscape theory’, where the image allows you
to understand power and control, or a somewhat intimate portrait of what Eyal Weizman called the ‘3 dimensionality of occupation’. The full footage of this project is in the public domain, and is still referenced by many studying Jerusalem city.

There were CCTV projects in Rostock at the G8 summit (Kneipness or Wellness at the camp), in Ljubliana piggy-backing on public CCTV via internet, in Bombay by mounting hi-res PTZ cameras on cinema halls and using the image live on IMAX screens, in our studio as a neighbourhood virtual tour, and as a general possibility in all lm work we do. One of the lessons from all this has been that CCTV, embedded in urban environments today, has become accepted without being fully digested. Its scope, duration and distribution remain somewhat in-assimilable into our existing human senses and existing cinematic genres. It has to do with an aesthetic of continuous scanning, extreme changes in scale (zoom-ability) and integration into urbanity in instrumental but invisible ways. CCTV itself is an infrastructure, i.e. it is also a system on which other things are built, a future that Michael Klier’s film The Giant, who angularly looked down onto German cities of the time, seemed to suggest already in 1984. The ‘Giants’ of today track cars and recognise people. How can we reconnect the vastness and inhumanity of CCTVs technological side to a perceptual system called cinema? This question is also related to others. In Amsterdam, a city with a rich tradition of new media theory and art, a poster at the Waag put it bluntly: ‘Smart city - Dumb citizens’. Of course this is a provocation, but it is also the type of local challenge In Cameras Res enters into.

I would like to ask about your work here with actors—individuals you have planted in certain scenes that add a new kind of narrative woven within the surveillance footage. Can you discuss their place in the work?

CAMP: Yes, we have used them before as well, such as with the above Manchester examples. The point in both instances is to introduce some doubt as to who is an actor and who isn’t. This creates a tension around awareness that is something like an uncanny reverse of fiction cinema. People are going around their daily lives, but there is some explicit or implicit understanding in everyone of being watched. Sometimes this spills over into ‘acting’, sometimes it doesn’t. Here they are arriving into the work as surprises, as special agents who have a connection to the inner project of the camera.

How has your work around the aesthetics and politics of visual security affected the other work you do—other films, organising, installations, or research?

CAMP: Let us answer in this way. No one at CAMP is on any social media platforms. This is not the internet we are interested in. With projects like and Indiancine. ma it has been about a different kind of attention to materials, and a series of friendships around building things and exchanging knowledge. In our art practice we are happy to parse through large amounts of data in DIY automated processes, or deploy digital flotsam of all kinds as parts of our films. These things come from living and breathing digital materials. At the same time, we’ve built book scanners and libraries, and in general believe that “access” is also about new sensual encounters that happen through and around the internet. This is different than with social media internet, where surveillance and dataveillance are the combined background rules to its community—aspects that are only now coming into a wider understanding.

Gallery: In Cameras Res
Bombay Tilts Down, 2022

13m 14s looped, seven channel environment with music
Filmed by CCTV camera from a single-point location in South-Central Mumbai.

Kochi Muziris Biennale

Bombay Tilts Down
13m 14s looped, seven channel environment

An Evening with CAMP

This artist talk accompanies Signals: How Video Transformed the World.
Organised by Stuart Comer, Michelle Kuo and Rattanamol SIngh Johal.

In Cameras Res at De Appel Amsterdam

On three screens, a city-symphony filmed by automated CCTV cameras in Amsterdam pushing their optical and motor 'patrolling' capacities to an extreme.

CCTV Landscape from Moulali-Entally

A single camera mounted on the roof of Gem Cinema brings us multifarious textures, factoids and fabulations

The Neighbour before the House

"The Neighbour Before the House deals with the effects and narrative remainders of a (warfare) technology and proposes a method of witnessing, a witness machine."

CCTV Landscape from Lower Parel

A 200-year neighbourhood story told through a single camera mounted on a cinema hall, 90 minutes.

Opening event

Friday 13th Oct 2017
5:30 pm to 7:00 pm
IMAX at PVR Phoenix
Monday 16th Oct 2017
5:30 pm to 7:00 pm
PVR Phoenix 6

Tales from the Networked Neighbourhood: The Cinema of CAMP

Five films by CAMP curated by Vassily Bourikas and Filmmaker Festival

21st march
6:00 pm Khirkeeyaan (2006) 17 mins
and Hum Logos (2012) 45 mins
at Careof DOCVA, Milan

22nd March
Cinema Palestrina, Milan
5:30 pm
The Neighbour before the House (2011) 60 mins
7:30 pm
From Gulf to Gulf to Gulf (2013), 83 mins
22:00 pm
The Country of the Blind, and Other Stories (2011), 60 mins

The Neighbour Before the House Screening at New Museum

Al Jaar Qabla Al Daar

CCTV video, 60 mins Screening and discussion with Ashok Sukumaran and Shaina Anand
New Museum Theater

New York
Saturday 16 July 2011 2:00pm

Screening: The neighbour before the house

الجار قبل الدار (Al jaar qabla al dar)

Screening of CAMP's Jerusalem project filmed by residents using a PTZ CCTV camera, followed by a talk.
The International Academy of Art Palestine.
October 15 2009
7:30 - 9:30 pm

The Neighbour before the House at Yerba Beuna Center for the Arts

Al Jaar Qabla Al Daar (The neighbour before the house)
CCTV video
72 minutes
is part of
The Matter Within
Yerba Buena Center for the Arts
San Francisco
October 15 2011 - January 29 2012

CCTV Social at Space Hamilton

Shaina Anand and Ashok Sukumaran's project CCTV Social is being shown as a 30-minute video at Space Hamilton, Seoul as part of the exhibition
"The Second Order", curated by Ji Yoon Yang.
Opening December 7th, 2010.

Artists talk by Ashok Sukumaran: "Postscript on the Order of Networks"
December 18th, 4pm

Al Jaar Qabla al Daar at Sharjah Biennial 10

A 72-minute film resulting from a CCTV video project shot in Jerusalem/ Al Quds with eight palestinian families, from and around their homes. Screenings are every 90 minutes starting 10 am, the last screening is at 8 pm. At Bait Al Serkal, Upto May 7, 2011.

CCTV TV: An evening with CAMP

In advance of CAMP's solo at De Appel and in collaboration with LIMA - a screening of two of the studio’s earlier acclaimed projects that examine surveillance, society, and cinematic apparatus.

CCTV Social

In March 2008 Shaina Anand collaborated with Manchester Metropolitan University and Arndale Shopping Centre to open working CCTV environments to a general audience. People normally 'enclosed' by these networks came into the control rooms to view, observe and monitor this condition, endemic in the UK.

A Photogenetic Line, 2019

A 100-foot long sequence of photo-cutouts, first shown at the Chennai Photo Biennale, March 2019

Matrix : Skulptur Projekt Münster, 2017

Of mother, womb, array, environment in which more specialised structures can grow.

Theater Münster
Neubrückenstraße 63
10 Jun - 1 Oct, 2017
Site-specific installation with Electric cable, switches, speakers, monitors, custom electronics.

Men-At-Work with Boxes in Stereo

20 mins, HD. 2 - channel installation
Cantonese, Mandarin
Filmed in Guangzhou at the Zhuhai International Container Terminal

The Country of the Sea

Single exposure solar cyanotype print on cotton fabric
CAMP with Shunya collective and Clark House Initiative 22 x 5 feet
An image of the sea as its own “country”, with frontier towns at its edges disorients an easy reading of this territory

Descendants, 2014

A three-channel installation from 8mm film From the Clark House family archives, sequenced in a timeline as above. Each screen is a different part of the same 8mm frame, usually a face.

From Gulf to Gulf to Gulf, 2013

Feature-length travelogue by sea between western India, eastern Africa and the Persian gulf. First shown at a purpose built outdoor cinema on the creekside in Sharjah in 2013, where many of the sailors gather. Shown in Documenta 13 in an abridged form, as part of the installation The Boat Modes.

83 mins. Original format(s): HDV, SDV, VHS, Cellphone videos (variable). Stereo audio and in-cameraphone music.

Destuffing Matrix

4 channel HDV, 8 minutes

Swearing-In-Whispers, 2011

A screenplay in Courier 12pt melodramatic format, spanning the first three days of lobbying for cabinet spots, in the wake of the Indian general elections of 2009. The dialogue is entirely from phone taps made by the government. The screenplay slows them down and asks: what kinds of environments and scenes may lie behind them, and how are they connected?

Printed screenplay and IVR-based phone line, audience can type in scene numbers to hear dialogue in the original voices. Also performed as a reading.

Hum Logos

Act II (Hum Logos) is a 45-minute audio film spliced from the collection of the Radia Tapes. It covers two months after the Indian general elections of 2009, with the new cabinet in power. The film asks: if debate around these tapes was about whether they are edited or not, or as Justice Mukhopadhay put it, "splice has been added", then what can further editing do?

All Works